Bullying Public shame can teach someone a valuable lesson.
Next How is my argumentative essay?
In high school, for a year, I ignored my studies. I began to party and misbehave. My friends from years before noticed this and turned away from me.
In an intoxicated state I cut my hair long, blonde, and hard to miss extremely short. This inch-long cut was my shameful badge. I walked around and felt the stares—everyone could see how much I had changed.
To them, I was going no where in life. I began to adopt their perspective. My behavior became more reckless. After isolating myself for a summer, I started anew in a private school. I got the chance to rediscover my studies and to start a new reputation—one that was positive. A sensitive person like me can not handle public humiliation.
I felt isolated, self-hating, miserable, and angry.
None of these foster positive character change. In fact, they only make a person more likely to repeat their crimes and act in a defensive even violent manner. This type of punishment is not a new idea; it has been referenced in literature from as far back as in The Scarlet Letter. This form of punishment puts our law enforcement workers in place of the puritans publicly shaming Hester for her adultery: Hester ends up running away with her lover to Europe, totally disregarding the Puritan lifestyle and laws.
This ancient form of punishment leaves a mark that can not be shaken as time passes. This image not only hurts one person, it affects all involved.
In punishing a person for a crime, we are supposed to be teaching them to do right—to grow as a person. Clearly, the shame tactic can lead a person to act out in defense, to become self-destructive, or angry, injurious, or even violent to others.
Why would we want to use punishment for for a nonviolen 2 following.Kahan explains there are different shaming punishments and the way you perform these punishments. He argues, “Shame is an effective, cheap, and humane alternative to imprisonment.” (Paragraph 3) The courts should choices shaming for a criminal punishment rather than imprisonment for smaller crimes.
скачать ^ Shame Is Worth a Try Dan M. Kahan Dan M, Kahan graduated from Middlebury College in and Harvard Law School in , where he served as president of the Harvard Law benjaminpohle.com clerked for Judge Harry Edwards of the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit in and for Justice Thurgood Marshall of the . Dan M.
Kahan’s “Shame is Worth a Try” was first published in the Boston Globe on August 5, In this essay, Kahan contends that the use of “shame” as a penalty of low level crimes is not only effective, but is an economical and humane alternative to . Shame Is Worth a Try Shame is Worth a Try - Argument Dan M.
Kahan Dan M. Kahan was born in and graduated from Middlebury College in and Harvard Law School in , where he served as president of the Harvard Law Review. Free Essays on Shame Is Worth a Try By Dan m Khan. Get help with your writing. 1 through In reading the two essays “Condemn the Crime, Not the Person,” by June Tangney and “Shame Is Worth a Try,” by Dan M.
Kahan people will see both sides of public shame. The essay that does not support this claim is the one that was written by June Tangney.